I’ve tried using the backward loop cast-on when I was making a scarf from Sally Melville’s Knit book because this is the method she recommended. I was getting holes so after fiddling around, I ended up doing the cable cast-on and knitting into the back of the stitch where the cast-on starts (my loose stitch was the one before the cast-on started).
For those that use the backward loop cast-on, how did you keep the edge tidy looking, like in the video? Mine were looking very uneven and if I wasn’t real careful, I’d have this excess yarn when I knitted back.
You do have to be very careful to get an even edge with the backward loop method. I can get it fairly even just by watching my tension. But for under the arm, it’s a quick, easy cast on for stitches that will be picked up later.
I prefer the invisible cast on over the backward loop though. The invisi cast on leaves perfect stitches for picking up later.
Having a loose st at the end of the row is very common, and is usually tightened up when it is knit as the first stitch in the next row. Whatever kind of cast on that is used, and whatever “holes” there are, you also have to consider if those stitches are going to be picked up or seamed. If this is the case, it really doesn’t matter in the end.
I used Heart Yarn Super Saver (large skein). I finished it last night and sent it through the washer and drywer. Came through beautiful. I am not at all embarrassed to give it to my brother for his new little girl. I am still challenged with seams but I am getting better.