Oh earthchick, are there good yarn stores in Indy…
Well I would definitely check out Mass Ave Knit Shop - it’s right off of I-65/70 in downtown Indianapolis - on Virginia Ave. It’s huge, they have tons of yarn and books and prices are reasonable. They also have a WHOLE ROOM devoted to yarn on sale!!! If you only have time to check out one store that would be it my friend. I will warn you that it’s a tad bit chaotic in there as there are only 2 employees ever working and they’re both juggling phones, the “register” (a calculator and a credit card maching), and answering the bagillion cutomers’ questions. But it’s well worth it.
If you have time to drive a little bit, I would also check out Sheep Street down in Morgantown on SR252. It’s a little bit farther south, so it might be too far for you to drive, but it’s such a nice store. It doesn’t have the selection that Mass Ave has, but it’s nestled in the countryside and they have like 90 sheep and 2 llamas living on the property. They have a special focus on spinning and weaving, but have lots of scrumptious yarn for knitting as well.
There’s another store on the northside of Indy that’s nice, but I wouldn’t venture all that way for it.
If you have any specific questions, feel free to PM me!