My silly fiancee wanted a Ravenclaw scarf from Harry Potter, with the book colors. I didn’t really get the bronze color right, but oh well, it is still being appreciated! It’s a tubey scarf, and even if you can’t tell in the picture, it’s HUGE. I think I did pretty good for my first thing ever. 
The videos on this site are SO helpful.
Looks fantastic. Very nicely done.
Excellent for a first!:yay:
I am amazed this is your first FO, it is wonderful!! Congrats and keep up the good work!
Thank you very much, I’ll be trying! 
It’s beautiful!! You’re a natural:thumbsup:
:cheering: Way to go, it looks awesome!
Looks great! It will be so nice and warm!! Awesome job!
Excellent first project. It looks like you have been doing it for years
You did great for a first FO! It looks marvelous 
I think the colors look great. Isn’t it nice to have your first piece be so appreciated by the recipient?
Beautiful scarf! You did a great job.
Wow, that’s beautiful! Amazing for a first FO!
It looks great!! :happydance:
Wow, I don’t think I could have given away my first FO! Great job!
That’s fabulous!
Oh definitely, it’s really encouraging. I’m working on a hat to match now, double-pointed needles are scary!
Great job! That’s really good for a first FO!
That’s great for your first, I’m on my 5th project and still intimidated with knitting with two or more colors on one project. I haven’t even tried yet, lol. . .
Oh, it’s really no big deal compared to other stuff! I’d really recommend the video about it on here, that’s what helped me. She really makes it clear.