Cascade 220 vs Ultra Alpaca

Ok- I’m thinking of making the Rogue sweater found here:

I’m stuck on my yarn choice… I’m making another pattern in Berroco Ultra Alpaca and I absolutely love the feel of it. However, I’m thinking there just isn’t a color I quite like, so I was thinking of going with cascade. I’ve used cascade for felting, but I’m not sure how it would feel for a pullover sweater. I would nearly always have at least a tshirt or somethin underneath, so I’m just wondering if it’s relatively soft for a sweater? I have a few balls of it at home and it seems to feel fine. Just figured I would ask…

Also, if I go the cascade route, I can go buy it tomorrow cuz I have enough $$, if I go with alpaca I would have to wait another payday :slight_smile:


I :heart: cascade 220, so I say go with that. Course, I’ve never really tried ultra alpaca, so this may not be accurate opinion, but I still love 220 :muah:

Have you seen these threads? Thread 1
Thread 2

Thanks for the links :slight_smile: I’m just wondering what people’s experiences are with cascade for sweaters… I’m thinkin it’s soft enough, but I’ve never made anything big with it.

I made my clogs with Cascade, but I honestly don’t think I’d make a sweater with it–especially if alpaca is my other option. :teehee: I don’t think it would be awful, but there are softer yarns out there. Just my picky opinion.

I knit a cardigan for DH using triple strand Cascade 220. It is not scratchy. It was a delight to work with. You won’t regret it.

[color=blue]Additionally, I think Cascade 220 wool will show the cables better! Alpaca and alpaca blends could fuzzy-up or blur the definition of the cables. [/color]

I know the alpaca is softer… I’m going in person to see if there is a color I like, but if not-- it’s probably going to be cascade. I think I would rather have a little less soft in a color I’ll actually wear. I’m thinking green would be gorgeous. I already have cascade around, so I did my gauge swatch…

The harder question-- I do technically have enough money right now to go buy the yarn, but I’m already working on another sweater. I really really wanna go to my LYS and buy the yarn… but I should be well behaved and wait till payday next friday. So… do I go buy it now or do I wait??? ARGH! such tough choices…

IMO Cascade 220 is too scratchy.

I could just wander to my LYS with a budget and feel and fondle till I find something I like :slight_smile:

Cascade 220 is great…I have a sweater made out of it that I only wear a tank top under and it doesn’t itch me at all. I think wool is a better choice than alpaca for Rogue…you want the cables to pop out and they might not with alpaca.