I'm think Peaches and Creme and Sugar and Cream are basically the same yarn, just different manufacturers. Although I'm sure there are people who would beg to differ. Anyway, you can now buy Peaches and Creme online from Elmore-Pisgah. http://www.elmore-pisgah.com/On%20Line%20Store.htm
It's actually a great yarn for dishcloths and rugs. The Mason-Dixon Ballband pattern actually comes from the Peaches and Creme label.
If you want something softer, like for a facecloth, you may want to try Knitpicks Shine.