Thank you, I found my sock it to me ruler from Knit Picks and realized that I have made the foot way too short for his shoe size. He wears a 9.5.
Yes, he is wearing the socks in the picture. I can see what you are talking about. I am going to keep them for myself and make him a new pair.
He did wear them all day yesterday even though they kept falling down. What a sweetie. I couldn't have dealt with it.
Thanks eveyone for your help. I learned a lesson on these and that's why I love knitting.