If you have 111 sts plus 9 on one side of the center st, how many do you have on the other? You shouldn't have that many - 239 minus 1 for the center stitch is divided by 2 is 119, so you have 1 too many which may have come on row 5 or even row 3 and that's why you've got 9 instead of 8. Count your total number of sts again, maybe you have one less on the other side of the center stitch.
Somewhere you added an extra yo or forgot a dec. Instead of ripping out, go back to row 5 and look at your sts. Name them - edge st, yo, 7 knits, yo, 1 knit, yo, 3 knits, double dec (did you dec 2 sts here or only 1?), 3 knits, yo, and so on. That's usually how you can find where the mistake was, and fix it by dropping down to that and doing it right.